The short answer
There is no universal deadline to exercise your options by December 2027. Whether timing matters depends on the kind of option you hold and when it creates taxable income.
- NSOs. Exercising an NSO into vested shares creates ordinary compensation income equal to the spread (fair market value minus strike price). Washington's 9.9% income tax starts with the 2028 tax year. If that compensation would otherwise land in 2028 or later, and your Washington base income exceeds the standard deduction, recognizing it in 2027 can reduce Washington tax.
- ISOs exercised and held. A qualifying ISO exercise-and-hold generally creates no regular federal taxable income, so the spread does not enter federal adjusted gross income, which is where Washington's tax base starts. The federal exposure is the alternative minimum tax (AMT), and Washington has no AMT. So the 2028 start date is not, by itself, a reason to exercise ISOs in 2027.
- ISOs sold early. A disqualifying disposition generally turns part of the ISO gain into ordinary income in the year of sale. That year, not the exercise year, is the one that matters.
Model the federal tax, AMT, cash needed, liquidity and your residency before you pick a date.
This post is part of our complete guide to Washington's new income tax. For the general question of when to exercise, apart from Washington, see When to Exercise Stock Options at a Startup.
In this guide
- How each exercise path is taxed
- Example: NSO exercise in December 2027 vs. January 2028
- ISOs: AMT and disqualifying dispositions
- Early exercise and 83(b) elections
- QSBS: tax at exercise vs. exclusion at sale
- Residency and sourcing
- Liquidity
- Planning checklist
- Open questions
How each exercise path is taxed
| Path | Federal tax event | Potential Washington implications (2028+) | Principal planning risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| NSO exercise into vested shares | Ordinary compensation at exercise equal to the spread (IRC §83; Treas. Reg. §1.83-7). Income tax withholding and FICA apply to employees. | The compensation is in federal AGI. If recognized in 2028 or later, it can increase Washington taxable income, which is calculated after applying the standard deduction and other applicable deductions (ESSB 6346). If recognized in 2027, it is outside the new tax. | Paying cash for the exercise and the tax on shares you can't sell. The stock can fall after exercise. |
| ISO exercise-and-hold | No regular tax at exercise (§421(a)). The spread is an AMT adjustment (§56(b)(3)). | The spread generally does not enter federal AGI, so it generally does not enter the Washington base at exercise. Washington has no AMT. A later sale is analyzed in the year of sale. | Federal AMT owed with no sale proceeds to pay it. Recovery through the AMT credit (§53) can take years. |
| ISO disqualifying disposition (sale within 2 years of grant or 1 year of exercise, §422(a)(1)) | Ordinary income in the year of sale. Ordinary compensation generally equals the exercise spread, subject to a limitation for certain sales below exercise-date fair market value; additional gain is capital gain. (§422) | If the sale happens in 2028 or later, the ordinary income is in federal AGI and can be Washington-taxable. How Washington sources it for nonresidents and part-year residents is unresolved (see open questions). | Exercising in 2027 and selling in 2028 can still create Washington ordinary income. |
| Early exercise into unvested shares, with timely 83(b) | The 83(b) election taxes the spread at transfer (often $0 if strike = FMV). No more compensation at vesting. For ISOs, the election matters only for AMT. | For early-exercised NSOs, a timely 83(b) election generally fixes compensation at transfer. Compensation recognized in 2027 is outside the new Washington income tax; later vesting alone generally creates no additional compensation. For ISOs, the election affects federal AMT and does not prevent a later disqualifying disposition from producing compensation potentially included in Washington’s tax base. (Form 6251 instructions) | Paying for shares that may never vest or may lose value. Missing the 30-day filing deadline. |
These are general federal rules. Plan terms, the company's valuation, and your full return change the outcome.
Example: NSO exercise in December 2027 vs. January 2028
Assumptions:
- You are a full-year Washington resident in both 2027 and 2028.
- You exercise 10,000 vested NSOs with a $1 strike when the shares are worth $11. The spread is $10 per share, or $100,000, and it is the same on both dates.
- Your other Washington base income already exhausts the standard deduction, so the whole $100,000 adds to Washington taxable income (ESSB 6346).
- Assume the entire $100,000 of compensation is taxed federally at 37% in either year.
- No credits, no other deductions or modifications, and no change in the tax rate.
- The example excludes federal employment taxes, AMT, any later sale, QSBS, the time value of paying tax earlier, and any change in the stock price.
Result:
| Exercise Dec. 2027 | Exercise Jan. 2028 | |
|---|---|---|
| NSO compensation | $100,000 | $100,000 |
| Washington income tax (9.9%) | $0 | $9,900 |
| Federal income tax at 37% marginal rate | $37,000 | $37,000 |
The Washington difference is $9,900, which is 9.9% of the spread. If only part of the spread increases Washington taxable income after deductions, the savings will be less than $9,900; if none does, the savings will be zero. Accelerating the exercise payment and potentially the federal tax payment is a real cost, and so is owning illiquid stock for longer.
ISOs: AMT and disqualifying dispositions
An ISO exercise-and-hold puts the spread in your AMT calculation, not your regular taxable income. A $10 spread on 10,000 shares is a $100,000 AMT adjustment, not a $100,000 tax bill. Whether you owe AMT depends on the exemption, the phaseout and the rest of your return (Form 6251). Multiplying the spread by 28% does not give you the AMT.
Spreading ISO exercises across tax years can reduce AMT. Spreading them across quarters of the same year generally does not.
If you sell ISO shares in the same calendar year you exercise them, the sale is a disqualifying disposition and the AMT adjustment generally goes away. If you sell in a later year but before the holding periods are met, the AMT adjustment from the exercise year stays.
Holding past December 31 does not make a disposition qualifying. You need both two years from grant and one year from exercise. And long-term capital gain is not automatically outside Washington tax: ESSB 6346 coordinates with Washington's separate capital gains tax (RCW 82.87), including a limited credit for capital gains tax paid. That interplay is outside the scope of this post.
For more on how ISOs and NSOs differ, see our ISO vs. NSO guide.
Early exercise and 83(b) elections
If your plan allows early exercise, you can buy unvested shares and file an 83(b) election within 30 days of the transfer. The election applies to the stock, not to the option.
- Early-exercised NSOs: the elected income is the transfer-date FMV minus the strike. At a $2 strike and $2 FMV, that's zero. Nothing more is taxed as compensation when the shares vest. A later sale at $10 is $8 of gain per share, and whether it is long-term or QSBS-eligible depends on the holding periods and the §1202 tests.
- Early-exercised ISOs: the election works for AMT only. It does not change the ISO holding periods or the disqualifying-disposition rules.
Early exercise is a bet on the company. If you leave before vesting, the company typically repurchases unvested shares at the lower of cost or value, and an 83(b) election doesn't give you back tax you paid on shares you lost.
QSBS: tax at exercise vs. exclusion at sale
Keep two questions separate.
1. What is taxed when you exercise. NSO compensation is taxed at exercise. QSBS does not shelter it. An ISO exercise-and-hold is an AMT question. QSBS does not change either.
2. What may be excluded when you sell. Section 1202 can exclude eligible gain on a later sale of qualified small business stock.
For options, the stock is acquired when you exercise, not when the option is granted. For vested shares acquired by exercise, the holding period generally begins the following day, not at option grant. For unvested NSO shares subject to §83, it generally begins after substantial vesting unless a valid §83(b) election starts it after transfer. Early-exercised ISOs require separate analysis. (Treas. Reg. §1.83-4(a); IRS Pub. 525)
- For stock acquired after July 4, 2025, the exclusion is 50% after three years, 75% after four and 100% after five. The per-issuer cap is $15 million or 10 times basis, if greater. Prior eligible gain taken into account under §1202 from the same issuer reduces the remaining dollar limit; coordination rules also apply to older shares sold in the same year. Because the limit counts eligible gain, the amount charged against it can be larger than the amount actually excluded when the exclusion percentage is below 100%. Two different dates matter. Your acquisition date decides which exclusion regime applies. The stock's issuance date decides which gross-assets threshold is tested: $75 million for stock issued after July 4, 2025, $50 million before. Both the $15 million limit and the $75 million threshold are indexed for inflation after 2026 (§1202).
- For stock acquired earlier, the exclusion generally requires more than five years and uses the prior $10 million cap.
So shares bought by cash exercise in 2027 reach the three-, four- and five-year marks in 2030, 2031 and 2032. A 2028 exercise moves each mark back a year. It does not lose QSBS eligibility because Washington's tax has started. An earlier exercise can also matter if the company is about to grow past the gross-assets limit.
Eligible gain that isn't excluded is not automatically ordinary income. Its character depends on the normal rules for the sale. Whether excluded QSBS gain is also outside Washington's taxes is a separate question; see Does QSBS Avoid Washington's New 9.9% Income Tax?.
For the eligibility tests, see our QSBS guide and Section 1202 checklist.
Residency and sourcing
For 2028, the standard deduction is $1 million, and spouses and registered domestic partners share it. Inflation adjustments begin in October 2029 (ESSB 6346 §316). Nonresidents and part-year residents get a proportionally reduced deduction (§315).
Residents are taxed on their whole Washington base income. Nonresidents are taxed on compensation for employment within Washington. If they worked both in and out of the state, it is apportioned by days worked in Washington or another method the Department of Revenue approves (ESSB 6346 §403). Part-year residents combine their resident-period income with their Washington-source nonresident-period income (§406).
The statute does not say how to source option income from service spread across several years and states. That matters if you moved into or out of Washington between grant and exercise. See our post on remote workers.
Liquidity
Cash is usually the binding constraint. Private-company employees usually can't do a same-day sale. A net exercise, if the plan allows it, has its own tax treatment. Borrowing to exercise adds repayment risk. A transfer restriction can stop you from selling shares without stopping you from exercising. Separate three questions: can you exercise, can you sell, and how much cash does each step need.
Planning checklist
- Option type: ISO, NSO, or a split grant. ISOs become NSOs to the extent the grant-date value of the stock under ISOs that first become exercisable in a calendar year exceeds $100,000. That limit is measured by stock value, not the exercise spread (§422(d)).
- Strike price and current FMV (latest 409A).
- Vesting: what's vested, and whether early exercise is allowed.
- Expiration: the option's term, plus the post-termination exercise window. It is often 90 days. To keep ISO treatment, you generally must exercise within three months after employment ends. For a qualifying disability, §422(c)(6) extends that lookback to one year (§422). For exercise after death, §421(c)(1) supplies special rules (§421). Neither one automatically extends the option's contractual expiration.
- Exercise cost: the strike times the number of shares.
- Taxes: federal regular tax, AMT, FICA on NSOs, and Washington tax under stated residency and year assumptions.
- Liquidity: where the cash for exercise and taxes comes from, and whether a sale is realistic.
- Sale restrictions: rights of first refusal, lockups, and company approval of transfers.
- Deadlines: the 30-day 83(b) deadline, the company's processing cutoff before December 31, ISO holding periods, and QSBS holding periods.
Open questions
- Multi-year sourcing. How Washington will apportion NSO income for nonresidents or part-year residents when the service was performed over several years. §403 uses days worked but doesn't say which period. I have not identified option-specific DOR guidance.
- Sourcing particular grants. Federal law already treats disqualifying-disposition amounts as compensation. What's unresolved is how Washington will apply its sourcing rules to particular grants and service periods.
Talk to us
If you hold options in a Washington company and are weighing a 2027 exercise, book a call and we'll go through your grant, your numbers and your timing.
This post is for educational purposes only and is not legal or tax advice.