Washington State Taxes

I-645: What We Should Take From the Vote

By Joe Wallin,

Published on Nov 4, 2026   —   3 min read

Summary

Early I-645 returns favor keeping Washington’s income tax. What the vote tells us, what it leaves to the courts, and why planning still matters.

I wanted I-645 to pass. The early returns suggest it won’t.

As of 9:08 a.m. on November 4, the Secretary of State’s unofficial results showed 58.12% against repeal and 41.88% in favor. Those results are preliminary, not certified, but that is a substantial margin.

The lesson isn’t that Washington voters have no concerns about an income tax. It’s that concerns about what the tax might become weren’t enough to persuade a majority to repeal the tax that exists today.

The Funding Argument Worked. Opponents Need a Better Answer.

Asking people to repeal a tax they don’t expect to pay is hard. The tax falls on someone else. The cost of repeal, as the ballot described it, falls on schools and health care: “This measure would decrease funding for public K-12 education, higher education (including universities and community colleges), and human services (primarily healthcare).”

In September, DHM Research tested that sentence, showing half of 800 Washington residents the official language and half the same description without it. With the sentence, repeal trailed 35% to 57%, with 8% unsure. Without it, 40% to 44%, with 16% unsure. With the funding sentence, support for repeal was five points lower, opposition was thirteen points higher, and the undecided share was eight points lower.

The stated reasons are more striking. Asked in their own words why they would vote no, 44% of opponents who saw the funding sentence cited protecting education funding. Among opponents who didn’t see it, 2% did.

That does not prove the ballot language decided the election. It was an online survey of residents, not likely voters, and repeal trailed in both versions. But it shows where the argument was fought: less over whether millionaires should pay more than over what happens to schools and health care if they don’t.

Opponents need a better answer to that. If we believe a different tax policy would leave Washington better able to support those services over time, we have to explain how.

A Tax on a Million-Dollar Year

Take a founder who normally earns $200,000. In 2028, the company is acquired, and nonqualified option exercises and a transaction bonus add $1.3 million of ordinary income, for a total of $1.5 million. After the $1 million deduction, which spouses and registered domestic partners share, roughly $500,000 is taxed at 9.9%: about $49,500, in a year when the founder’s salary never changed.

Gain on the founder’s shares is treated differently. Section 302 generally removes long-term capital gains from the income-tax base, but taxpayers who owe Washington capital gains tax must add back their taxable Washington capital gains plus the amount of the capital gains standard deduction. A nonrefundable credit coordinates the two taxes. Gain excluded under Section 1202, or covered by the family-business deduction in RCW 82.87.070, generally stays out.

Here's how that works. Say a single filer in 2028 has $3 million of salary and $800,000 of taxable Washington capital gains—about $1.08 million of gain before the capital gains standard deduction (using the 2025 deduction of $278,000; the 2028 figure will be indexed). The gain comes out of the income-tax base and then goes back in, deduction and all, so Washington taxable income is about $3.08 million after the $1 million deduction. The income tax is about $304,700. The capital gains tax is $56,000 (7% of $800,000), and it's credited against the income tax, leaving about $248,700 of income tax. Total: about $304,700, versus $198,000 on the salary alone. In effect, the whole gain is taxed once, at 9.9%.

This is not necessarily a tax on people who earn $1 million every year. It can be a tax on a million-dollar year.

The Vote Did Not Decide the Constitutional Question

The tax faces a challenge under article VII of the Washington Constitution in Petter v. State of Washington, pending in Klickitat County Superior Court, with summary judgment set for hearing on February 5, 2027. Voters decided whether to repeal the tax, not whether the Constitution allows it. That is for the courts, and no one should make financial decisions assuming they will strike it down. I’m following the case on the I-645 Tracker.

The election did not settle whether this is good tax policy. It did tell those of us who opposed it that we have not yet persuaded a majority of voters. That is worth understanding. And for anyone planning a business sale, a major compensation event, or a move, the practical task now is to understand the law, not assume it will disappear.

Share on Facebook Share on Linkedin Share on Twitter Send by email

Subscribe to the newsletter

Subscribe to the newsletter for the latest news and work updates straight to your inbox, every week.

Subscribe
Planning a sale, move, or exit before 2028? Book a 20-minute intro call →
Holding QSBS? Get a Section 1202 issue-spotting review →
Planning for Washington’s 9.9% income tax, effective January 1, 2028? Get the Tax Planning Guide →